Under New York Mayor Bloomberg's proposed big soda ban, soda sizes at the movies and elsewhere would have to shrink, and so would the fun, some people say.
Under New York Mayor Bloomberg's proposed big soda ban, soda sizes at the movies and elsewhere would have to shrink, and so would the fun, some people say.
Both sides have been pouring money into ad campaigns, slinging mud and twisting words. But this is not the Presidential election, it's the battle for soda.
Today, a panel in New York City is expected to approve the ban of soda and other sugar-sweetened beverages in containers larger than 16 ounces in restaurants, street carts and stadiums.
New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg is known for his far-reaching policies when it comes to public health. He is, after all, responsible for snuffing out New Yorkers' cigarettes. But this soda restriction proposal seemed to be one step too far for many people.
Opinions have been flying all summer, both on the street and in highbrow places like The Atlantic, the New Yorker and the New York Times. In fact, a recent New York Times poll shows 60 percent of New Yorkers oppose the ban, even though 51 percent reported drinking soda less than once a week or never.
So why all the vitriol over soda?
It turns out the emotional response to the issue runs deeper than our physical attachment to giant fizzy drinks.
"Humans are unique in the meaning they attach to food," Craig Hadley, professor of anthropology at Emory University and the President of the Society for Anthropology of Food and Nutrition tells The Salt.
According to Hadley, our identities are wrapped up in our food choices. "We see this when we associate certain ethnic groups with certain foods, athletes with specific diets, or vegetarians with political ideologies." (Think Michael Phelps and his Olympic diet, or the vegan musician Moby and his anti-factory farming agenda.)
Still, though, this push for the freedom to drink soda feels counter intuitive in this age of organic farming, Michelle Obama and Community Supported Agriculture. Hadley thinks soda hits a nerve because it's a choice that's being taken away.
"Studies from experimental economics and social psychology over and over demonstrate that people are more sensitive to a loss than a gain," he says.
Of course, some would argue that the government restricts choices about what we ingest all the time. There are restrictions on what time we can buy alcohol and at what age we can buy cigarettes.
Food, though, is different, according to Kathryn Oths, a professor of Anthropology at the University of Alabama. Soda and other similar products, "[are] cognitively mapped as food or nourishment, not as vices or extras."
"Soda is not a controlled substance, but rather sits on the dining room table or in the fridge, available to all. For some, to appear to be taking away one's soda ... is chipping away at some of the remaining pleasures that people have available to them," says Oths.
Despite all of this, Oths predicts people will get used to the soda ban in time, just as they did with Bloomberg's public smoking ban. "Initial studies have shown an association between getting soda out of schools and declining BMI in those schools, which could help make the idea more acceptable eventually," she says.
New Yorkers will find out in March 2013, when the ban is expected to officially go into effect.
Beating Cancer with Baking Soda CURE CANCER 75-Don Cure Cancer with Baking Soda? By Paul Fassa August 10, 2010 The amazing abundance of alternative cancer treatments and cancer cures is more than most ... Topic Galleries -- OrlandoSentinel.com - Orlando news, information ... Topic galleries provide easy access to stories and photos about people, places, organizations, events and subjects of interest to you. They bring together rich ... New York Soda Ban: Companies Launch Big Campaign Against Bloomberg ... New York Soda Ban: Companies Launch Big Campaign Against Bloomberg's Proposal (AUDIO) Michigan Policy Network - Michigan Smoking Ban Exemptions and ... Written by Megan Mulder Thursday, 04 February 2010 04:44 An updated story on problems associated with enforcing the state smoking ban is available here: Smoking Ban ... Video - Breaking News Videos from CNN.com Biden: America's best days are aheadWatch VP Joe Bidens entire speech Michael Bloomberg's soda ban: the CEO of New York Inc strikes ... Jason Farago: It's not that using government to tackle obesity is wrong, but this mayor has eroded New York's democratic culture with his diktats New York News, Local News, Weather, Traffic, Entertainment ... Get local NY news, weather, traffic, and entertainment, plus NYC breaking news, business, green, and national news from NBC New York. Topic Galleries -- South Florida Sun-Sentinel.com Topic galleries provide easy access to stories and photos about people, places, organizations, events and subjects of interest to you. They bring together rich ... Health News & Articles Healthy Living - ABC News Get the latest health news from Dr. Richard Besser. Here you'll find stories about new medical research, the latest health care trends and health issues that affect ... The Food Police - A K Dart dot com Introduction: As if there wasn't already enough government intervention in the everyday decisions made by a "free" people, there is a new regulatory fad underway ...
No comments:
Post a Comment