Enlarge image Farmed Atlantic salmon was sometimes labeled at "wild salmon," researchers found when the tested seafood sold in New York City.
Farmed Atlantic salmon was sometimes labeled at "wild salmon," researchers found when the tested seafood sold in New York City.
If you buy fish in New York City, particularly from a small market or restaurant, there's a pretty good chance it won't be the fish it claims to be.
An ocean conservation group announced today that three in five retail outlets it visited, including 100 percent of sushi restaurants, were selling mislabeled fish. The report is just the latest in a string of investigations revealing that seafood mislabeling is commonplace.
The researchers, from the group Oceana, collected 142 fish samples earlier this year from 81 retail outlets, including large grocery stores, corner bodegas, high-end restaurants, and sushi bars. They analyzed the samples using DNA barcoding, and found that 39 percent of the fish were labeled as other species.
Farm-raised Atlantic salmon had been substituted for wild-caught salmon, they found. Ocean perch, tilapia, and goldbanded jobfish were sold as red snapper. Fish labeled "white tuna" was escolar, which can cause acute gastrointestinal problems. And one serving of halibut was really tilefish, a species with so much mercury that the Food and Drug Administration has placed it on the do-not-eat list for pregnant women and young children.
The study didn't address who exactly is responsible for the mislabeling whether at the supplier or the retail level. "That's for the enforcers," notes Kimberly Warner, a senior scientist at Oceana.
Last year the Boston Globe reported that 48 percent of fish in Massachusetts were mislabeled, similar to findings in Los Angeles (55 percent) and Miami (31 percent). A follow-up from the Globe published earlier this month found that 76 percent of fish in a new survey were mislabeled.
And in 2008, two New York City high school students conducted their own DNA study of four restaurants and 10 grocery stores in Manhattan and found that a quarter of the fish they sampled were mislabeled.
Warner says that traceability a better system that would make it easier to track seafood from net to plate would help to eliminate the fraud. "We have a very complex and murky seafood chain with no traceability."
A bill introduced to Congress in July is intended to address seafood fraud. Fish suppliers, restaurants, and stores would have to provide more information to their customers about the seafood they sell. In addition, the bill would require more coordination between the FDA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration the two government agencies responsible for food and fisheries regulation.
But Gavin Gibbons, a spokesman for the National Fisheries Institute, says that the enforcement of current law is what's really needed. "If there were more enforcement on the ground as opposed to more regulations on the books, we think we'd be seeing less fraud," Gibbons says.
Figuring out the source of a fishy fraud, whether it's a retail outlet or a supplier, Gibbons says, "is really not that hard." With only a DNA test, a menu, and an invoice, an enforcer can see that if the "invoice matches the menu and not the DNA, then you know that the supplier was the source of the fraud."
In the absence of better enforcement, Gibbons suggests that consumers ask their local shop or restaurant if their fish supplier is a member of the Better Seafood Board, an industry group that works to eliminate fish fraud.
The source of mislabeling isn't always greed sometimes two species look too similar even for fishermen to tell them apart. But when some fish sellers are playing fair and others are getting away with substituting cheaper species for more expensive ones, "it harms a lot of people," Warner notes, "not just the consumer."
Animal News, The Podcast Because Animals Refuse To Speak English Because Animals Refuse To Speak English ... Tabloid Thursday: La Chupacabra! Pterosaurs are Pteriffying; Tabloid Thursday: Kung-Fu White-Claw Asiatic Brown Bear Past Press Releases Newsroom News from CSPI Center for ... Since 1971, the Center for Science in the Public Interest has been a strong advocate for nutrition and health, food safety, alcohol policy, and sound science. Its ... Food Safety News OSU Food Safety Program By Dan Flynn. At least 29 children and 17 adults are now known to have been infected with the dangerous O157:H7 strain of E. coli while attending the Cleveland County ... Ruins of the Second Gilded Age MetaFilter The New York Times commissioned Portuguese photographer Edgar Martins to travel around the United States and take photographs of abandoned construction projects left ... Apple - Start Find My iPhone, iPad, or iPod touch. Free. Set up your iPhone, iPad, or new iPod touch. Then find it on a map if you misplace it. Health and Medicine - AlternativeNews.com AMAZING MUST WATCH: 'I'm Here' - Off-label use Ambien awakens stroke victim from vegetative state to full speech, cognition! (NBC Rock Center w/Brian Williams) Business News, Personal Finance and Money News - ABC News Find the latest business news on Wall Street, jobs and the economy, the housing market, personal finance and money investments and much more on ABC News no loss for words: Dan Brown is a fraud: A list of errors in ... Dan Brown, author of the immensely popular The Da Vinci Code and Angels and Demons, makes a big deal of the accuracy of his books and the time he spends researching them. Paradox Online - Guest Articles - Metagroups Community Calendar Short e-mail reminders are sent out twice a week: Monday and Friday. They redirect you to an online reminder that includes events scheduled each weekend, plus special ... The Fish Barcode of Life (FISH-BOL) special issue Sergios ... Type to search for People, Research Interests and Universities. Searching... The Fish Barcode of Life (FISH-BOL) special issue more
No comments:
Post a Comment