Enlarge image i This 5-foot plexiglass piece of art, resembling a freshly poured glass of milk, sits near the door to the headquarters of the Dairy Farmers of America, in Kansas City, Mo.
This 5-foot plexiglass piece of art, resembling a freshly poured glass of milk, sits near the door to the headquarters of the Dairy Farmers of America, in Kansas City, Mo.
Farmers who had hoped to get some answers on why prices for their raw milk went into free fall a decade ago were disappointed Tuesday by the settlement of a case accusing the Dairy Farmers of America, Inc., of creating a milk monopoly in the Southeast.
Dairy farmers and industry observers had hoped for their day in court after years of delays in the large class-action suit. But the day before the trial was to start in federal court in Tennessee, DFA announced a $158.6 million deal, saying they didn't want to risk going to trial.
Although the payout will only go to farmers in the Southeast, the case was being watched as an indicator of the national industry, which has faced dramatic changes as it has become more industrialized and family farmers have been squeezed out.
But things were worse in the Southeast, where DFA, a food cooperative that was supposed to represent its 1,700 member farmers, instead made a deal with Dean Foods, the large food company based in Dallas, back in 2001. As NPR's John Burnett reported in 2009, the deal made the milk industry icon Elsie the Cow look instead like Gordon Gekko.
The farmers filed suit in 2007, alleging that DFA and Dean conspired to eliminate competition in the Southeast and suppress the prices they would pay farmers for raw milk. In turn, executives made deals that made them rich. DFA's former CEO, Gary Hanman, who was named in the suit, was paid $31.6 million during his seven years as head of the cooperative. Dean's former CEO, Gregg Engles, was paid $156 million, according to published reports.
Dean settled its case last summer for $145 million. The DFA settled on Tuesday.
"Where inherently there's risk when you go to trial, the member's interest would be better served by making a business decision to put it behind us," says DFA CEO Rick Smith, who announced his organization's settlement, in which the cooperative admitted no wrongdoing.
Veterinarian Sam Galphin, who has worked in Raleigh, N.C., for 30 years, is unhappy with that settlement, saying farmers will see very little money and will get no relief from a bad market that makes it impossible to make any money. He calls the DFA-Dean deal a "cartel" and bristles at describing it as an industry consolidation.
"When I started in North Carolina, there were 1,200 dairies. Today there are less than 300. In South Carolina, there were 800 dairies. Today there are less than 100," he says. "That's not just consolidation."
Peter Carstensen, a University of Wisconsin Madison law professor who has watched the case for years, says he was not surprised by the settlement, but he was disappointed because most of the dairy farmers' problems won't be addressed.
"While it is nice that the farmers get some modest compensation for the harm that they suffered in the past, they remain at risk, as does the entire milk industry, by the failure to use this case to develop better, more open, and non-discriminatory access to markets for milk," he says.
The U.S. Department of Justice investigated the industry on anti-trust issues during the George W. Bush administration but didn't file any charges. That's why Carstensen had hoped that the DFA case would go to trial, so that the judge could perhaps establish restrictions on DFA and more family farmers could be competitive.
The farmers had sought $1.2 billion in damages from DFA. Combined with the Dean settlement, the dairy farmers should share more than $300 million.
Peggy Lowe is a reporter for Harvest Public Media.
Dairy Farmer - Ian Potter Associates- The only name for milk quota ... December 2012 Dairy Farmer Article . Recently I succeeded in taking-up a long-standing invitation from Dairy Crest to visit its HQ and have a go at its Competition ... News Archives - Canadian Business OTTAWA The federal Opposition is calling on the Harper government to prevent credit card companies from charging businesses higher fees for using premium cards. Class Action Lawsuit and Settlement News Active Investigations. Actos Bladder Cancer Class Action Lawsuit Investigation; Propecia Loss of Sex Drive, Sexual Dysfunction Class Action Lawsuit Settlement ... American Agriculturist by Farm Progress - Agriculture's Leading ... Local News. PA Mennonite Agribusiness Appeals Federal Contraception Mandate. Mennonite business appeals federal court rejection of their claim that Obamacare's ... Growing Your Baby Parenthood from Pregnancy to Pre-school ... Parents Welcome Rare Quads After Being Told They Couldnt Conceive. To conceive quadruplets naturally, you have to beat ... Monsanto A Sustainable Agriculture Company If there were one word to explain what Monsanto is about, it would have to be farmers. It is our purpose to help them meet the needs of a growing population -- by ... Organic Consumers Association: Millions Against Monsanto Campaign Consumers have the right to know what is in their food! OCA is calling on retailers to pledge voluntary compliance with our Truth-in-Labeling campaign by clearly ... Bayer AG : Corporate Crimes - Homepage : Latest News from ... Corporate Watch c/o Freedom Press Angel Alley 84b Whitechapel High Street London, E1 7QX t: +44 (0)207 426 0005 e: contact[at]corporatewatch.org
No comments:
Post a Comment