This election season, Californians are being served up gargantuan helpings of advertising about a proposal to require food in the Golden State to be labeled if it includes genetically modified ingredients.
On November 6, voters will decide on Proposition 37. Proponents say people simply have a right to know what's in their food. The food and biotechnology industry argues that labeling creates a false impression that there's something amiss about foods that come from engineered crops.
While lots of labels tout their lack of genetically modified ingredients, if California's Prop. 37 succeeds, foods containing GMOs would have to be labeled.
While lots of labels tout their lack of genetically modified ingredients, if California's Prop. 37 succeeds, foods containing GMOs would have to be labeled.
And now the world's largest general scientific society is weighing in on the debate.
The American Association for the Advancement of Science says labeling would "mislead and falsely alarm consumers." The AAAS best known for publishing Science magazine says genetically modified foods are fundamentally no different from conventionally bred foods. In fact, the organization says they are tested more extensively than most new crop varieties.
Genetically modified crops are already common. Most of the corn and soy grown in this country is engineered. Proponents say this technology can improve productivity to feed an ever-growing world. Scientists insert or manipulate a few specific genes in these foods, for example adding natural pesticides or making crops resistant to herbicides, which farmers can then spray more easily instead of mechanically tilling the soil. This no-till method decreases soil erosion but increases herbicide use.
Opponents of genetically modified foods have a variety of concerns. Some have a gut feeling that these crops are unwholesome. Others worry that the technology is driven simply by corporate profits for seed companies as well as herbicide producers. Indeed, industry has poured nearly $41 million into advertising to defeat the ballot measure, with "No on 37" TV and radio ads warning that the labels could lead to higher prices at the store, according to The Wall Street Journal. (Check out one of those ads below.)
Sometimes worries about genetically modified foods are expressed as concern over food safety, but the AAAS says that concern isn't supported by the science.
"Civilization rests on people's ability to modify plants to make them more suitable as food, feed and fiber plants and all of these modifications are genetic," the AAAS statement says.
"Modern molecular genetics and the invention of large-scale DNA sequencing methods have fueled rapid advances in our knowledge of how genes work and what they do, permitting the development of new methods that allow the very precise addition of useful traits to crops, such as the ability to resist an insect pest or a viral disease, much as immunizations protect people from disease."
But California voters aren't necessarily driven by the science of this question.
For example, many celebrity chefs, led by Alice Waters from Chez Panisse in Berkeley, have signed a petition supporting Proposition 37. Some 1,200 chefs are now voicing their support for the measure, even though restaurant food is exempt.
The petition says: "It is our duty to nourish our guests, both in body and soul. However, we can't prepare the best food we know how when information about the ingredients we purchase is hidden from us with labels that are missing basic facts. This includes foods that are genetically engineered or contain genetically modified organisms."
By framing this issue as a matter of transparency, proponents of food labeling can neatly sidestep the science of the matter.
But the issue is far from settled. According to a Los Angeles Times poll, proponents and opponents are evenly split on the issue. And 20 other states are considering similar legislation.
Monsanto - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Monsanto Company (NYSE: MON) is a publicly traded American multinational agricultural biotechnology corporation. It is a leading producer of the herbicide glyphosate ... School Food, GMOs and CAFOs Safe & Healthy School Food Coalition/NYC The great PAN has released a new report with all the recent hard science on pesticides and the damage they are doing to our children. Pesticides disrupt our hormonal ... Genetic Literacy Project Crop genome plasticity and its relevance to food safety of genetically engineered breeding stacks Claire Halpin Natalie Weber Plant Physiology Redding Record Searchlight: Local Redding, California News ... Proposition 37 would require the labeling of genetically modified foods in California. Supporters say it would provide important consumer information, and opponents ... Topic Galleries -- chicagotribune.com - Chicago Tribune: Chicago ... Topic galleries provide easy access to stories and photos about people, places, organizations, events and subjects of interest to you. They bring together rich ... Take Action Genetic RouletteGenetic Roulette After watching Genetic Roulette please consider taking the following action steps below. Please also leave your comments about the movie Genetic Roulette. U.S. News National News - Latest Headlines, Videos, Photos - ABC ... ABC News reports on United States politics, crime, education, legal stories, celebrities, weather, the economy and more Food labeling: Should environmentalists be pro-GM? Genetic ... Half a century on from Rachel Carsons seminal Silent Spring, debate rages over GM food labeling proposals. Dark Politicks Latest Articles for Oct 22nd 2012Dark Politricks ... View the latest alternative news for Oct 22nd 2012 that the mainstream media doesn't want you to know about here on DarkPolitricks.com Organic Consumers Association: Millions Against Monsanto Support the California GMO Labeling Ballot Initiative California is poised to be the first state with mandatory GMO labeling laws through the 2012 California Ballot ...
